State of Oregon unrepentantly attempted to penalize bakers $135,000 for refusing to send a message that conflicts with their religious convictions.
The government should never compel Americans to speak a message that conflicts with their deepest convictions. But that’s exactly what the State of Oregon did to Aaron and Melissa Klein, owners of the “Sweet Cakes by Melissa” bakery. Because of their Christian convictions, the Kleins declined to design and create a custom cake to celebrate a same-sex wedding. As a result, the State of Oregon punished them with a $135,000 penalty and a gag order. In June 2023, the U.S. Supreme Court vacated the Oregon court’s ruling against the Kleins, and return the case once again to the state.
“It’s a win when the Supreme Court vacates a bad lower court decision like it did for Aaron and Melissa today, but the case is not over,” said Kelly Shackelford, President, CEO, and Chief Counsel to First Liberty. “The Kleins have been fighting for the First Amendment for over a decade and we will stand with them no matter how long it takes to get the victory they deserve.”
Source: Sweet Cakes by Melissa Case – Cases – First Liberty
I have been following this case for a long time. In 2013 two lesbians, Laurel and Rachel Bowman-Cryer, singled out Sweet Cakes by Melissa because of their Christian faith and attempted to force the Kleins to create a same-sex wedding cake. They then used the full force of the corrupt Oregon government in an attempt destroy the business when Kleins refused. In following decade the Kleins have been in and out of court, their lives completely disrupted with massive legal bills and fines, victims of activists within and without state government. The Supreme Court still has only handed them a temporary reprieve, not a solid win, so they remain at the mercy of the Oregon government which far more corrupt today then it was a decade ago.
The Bowman-Cryers did not come out of this free and easy. They foolishly failed to foresee the target they would put on their back by getting caught up in their LGBTQ+ activism. They already had acceptance, marriage, and a child together. That was not enough. They wanted… something more. They wanted to attack innocent people. Unfortunately for them, their actions did not occur in a vacuum. There were repercussions. While they caused the Kleins incredible legal and financial problems, they also caused an incredible groundswell of moral support for the Kleins within the community and around the nation. The Kleins are good people. The Bowman-Cryers proved they were not cut from the same cloth.
The Bowman-Cryers gave themselves the exact opposite of what they dished to the Kleins. While they were convenient tools for anti-Christian Oregon politicians like Brad Avakian and Ellen Rosenblum, the lesbians soon found out the State of Oregon was not there for moral support, and did not particularly care what happened to them. They got used and tossed aside.
While “the law” was on their side, much of the community was not. The Bowman-Cryers needlessly started a fight, not only with the Kleins, but with every American who values freedom of religion. While the vast majority of us remained civil, not wanting to threaten or harm the Bowman-Cryers, a lot of hate and cruelty has been directed their way on top of legitimate public criticism. Not because they are a married same-sex couple with a daughter, no, they put themselves in their position because they refused to live and let live. They demanded respect without giving respect. They wanted to compel others to violate their deeply held faith and it backfired. They made themselves into social pariahs.
My guess is, if these two women could go back in time, they would simply go to any one of the hundreds of secular bakeries in the Portland Metro area and leave the Kleins alone. If they had asked for my advice back in the day, I would have told them not to pick fights unless you can accept the consequences of losing, and no matter the outcome for the Kleins, the Bowman-Cryers lost. There is a time to keep your mouth shut and stop being so disagreeable.